Tuesday, 29 April 2014

Gaslighting, Agency, and Continuity



                I was thinking today about continuity. My initial thoughts were not, initially, in the narrative sense of continuity, but in the sense of our frame of existence. Aside from memories and physical evidence, we have no way of verifying if events in the past actually happened. Normally, this isn’t a concern, memory and physical evidence is more than enough. Those facts change when it comes to games.

                When a game starts, players typically have a back-story for their character and then the GM sets the scene. Back-stories represent an individual character’s memories of the past and the current scene is, in effect, the present. As play progresses, especially if the GM improvises, individual scenes lose some details, the degree of which depends on the group’s memories. I’ve lost notes before and the names or descriptions of NPCs change as I’m forced to improvise the local bartender again.

                A tactic I’ve used in horror or suspense gaming is something called Gaslighting. Now, in the real world, this is a pretty horrible thing to do to someone. In the context of a game, it can help put the players on edge, something I think good horror roleplaying needs. As an aside, there is a very fine line when using tactics like this on your players. I would never condone, for example, using spiders to scare an extremely arachnophobic player. Horror roleplaying is fun in the same way a horror movie is fun. The players want to be scared, but there is a breach of trust if you use information you know about your players to upset them. Nevertheless, I digress.

                Gaslighting, to put it simply, is subtle manipulation of information in order to have people question their senses and their memory. The players are entirely reliant on the GM for information about the game world, barring any notes they take. Take the local bartender I mentioned earlier, for example. If I say in one scene that the bartender’s name is Rachel and in then, in the next session mention Rory the bartender that can either be a mistake in continuity or deliberate. If the players are a particular location looking for clues, or something similar, changing small details can serve to heighten the tension. If I mention a brass bell on a blue ribbon, and then later, describe the ribbon as black, this can throw players off. If you use this tactic, use it subtly and sparingly. Using it too much robs the players of their agency. For that matter, using it at all robs the players of agency in a small way.

                When you change information intentionally, your players cannot act on information previously given. If I say that a room has a door on the left, right, and center players choose a course of action based on that information. If I change that detail by removing the center door, this invalidates an option that the players might have picked. This violation of player agency can, if done right, put your players on edge. Their memories and the physical reality of the world don’t match up. Do it too much and it’s more annoying than anything else.  

                Now, I brought up back-story before for a reason. I wouldn’t recommend directly contradicting or changing anything in a player’s back-story. They put in the effort to bring material to your table, even if they’re the only one informed by it. By altering it, you are again, violating both the trust of your players and their agency. As GM, you are allowed a certain degree of editorial control of the content of the material your players bring to the table, but that is something you work out with the player, hopefully before the first session even starts. 

A way to manipulate the information your players bring to the table without cheapening their efforts is to change the context. Work with the material the players include in their back-stories to create narrative twists and turns. Don’t contradict any facts your players create, but write material to cast those facts in a different light. 

In terms of campaign structure, you can use manipulation of facts as the basis of a game. Completely invalidating the advice I gave earlier, separate your player’s back-stories into discrete events. Sort these events into two categories, factual and non-factual. With these details, you create a horror or investigative plot in which the mystery is the character’s own back-stories. With this set-up, you are not only engaging with the materials your players create, but also making it the focus of the game. I wouldn’t spring this kind of game on your players, make sure their okay with it first, possibly by trying some other tricks involving back-story first.

Tuesday, 22 April 2014

Podcasts and Panels: The Hourglass Model in Adventure Design



I attended a panel at my local gaming convention earlier this year and attended a couple of panels on RPG design. I’m also a big fan of podcasts, one of which is the Co-optional Podcast put on by the Polaris Network on Youtube. Both are about gaming (tabletop and video respectively), but I didn’t expect to encounter thoughts on the same style of design in both.

In both instances, panelists brought up a style of plot Alex Flagg referred to as the hourglass model. He used it to describe a method of adventure design, so that’s the way I’ll describe it, as it fits better with the general theme of this blog. You start with a base point, the hook that introduces characters to the plot, or the introduction to the campaign. From there, you move out into a sandbox style of play in which you defeat challenges that lead you closer to a major event. This major event acts as a bottleneck between the sandbox style of play and the rest of the adventure. Completing the bottleneck event leads the players to a new hook and into a second sandbox. 

On the Co-optional Podcast, this was an example of a problem with Mass Effect. It always funnels you towards a particular set piece, despite having a free roam style of play, typically. I can’t say for sure how true this is, having only really played the first game. This was a problem with the design and took away from their enjoyment of the game. Now, when I was at the panel, I thought that this model was an improvement on the usual sandbox style of design because it gave forward momentum and a chance to create impressive set pieces.

One of the biggest issues, I think, with sandbox games in tabletop gaming is prep time. A linear story requires the least amount of preparation but grants the least player agency. A branching story has a balance between prep time and player agency. Sandbox style play has an immense amount of prep time but grants the most agency to players, often to the point of overwhelming them. To me, the hourglass style is a mix of the branching story and the sandbox. Players are moving towards the bottleneck but can plan how to do so. Having a bottleneck means that you can spend the time making an impressive set piece with complex mechanics or narrative impact without worrying that your players will miss it entirely. Your sandbox play can be looser, evolving organically in play because these important moments have more impact on the players.

Now, I’m a designer and GM first and a player second so my views on adventure/ campaign design are skewed towards set up and structure more than they are playability. When I heard the panelists on the Co-optional podcast cite this design philosophy as a problem I had a few issues. Notably, these people are players, not designers. I saw three possibilities:
1)      This style of game only works in tabletop
2)      This style of game is more appealing to designers than players
3)      This style of play is not for everyone

I don’t have an answer. The reason for this post is to explain the problem. I may post later explaining the options in detail. Also, I may look at player agency and how it relates to design choices. Also, listed below are some links to the podcasts and panels I referred to today as well as Alex Flagg’s company. At time of posting, the recording of the Co-optional Podcast episode I mentioned isn’t up.


Relevant Links:



Wednesday, 16 April 2014

Events in Fisher Kings

I was going to do the introduction to this setting as a piece of short fiction but that sort of stalled. Hopefully, I'll be able to finish it, or something like it in the near future. In the meantime, I'm posting a short introduction and timeline for Fisher Kings.

The game takes place in a fictional version of Bellingham, WA and the surrounding towns. The fictional city on this spot is called Portsmouth. Setting it in a fictional city gave me the freedom to essentially arrange the landscape however I chose. I divided the town into four districts, using the name of towns in the area.

1) Portsmouth (the district) is primarily industrial, mostly abandoned with the decline of heavy industry in the area. It is home to the majority of the city's squatters and homeless. What isn't factories and warehouses, abandoned or not, is predominantly row houses and other low income housing.

2) Bellingham (again, the district) is the city's downtown core as well as home to many apartments, large and small. Over the course of the game, this region of town has taken the most beating, having hosted multiple superpowered brawls.

3) Fairhaven is an upper class district with trendy stores and expensive houses and apartments. For the first eight or so sessions, the group was based here.

4) Sehome is a middle class district mostly made up of suburbs. The very rich tend to live on the border between here and Fairhaven. The PCs have spent very little time here. I don't write much in the way of crime-fighting hooks in suburban America, oddly enough.

Structurally, the game is in a sandbox style of play with occasional moments in which I lean in to take narrative control in order to have a structured adventure, but I've only done that twice so far. So, with that in mind, here is the spoiler free timeline for the background and first few sessions. I'll post a character overview soon.


Timeline



August 16th 2013- The night sky is filled with a strange pulsing ring of light. This ring is visible around the world and stays in place for exactly one rotation of the Earth.

August 17th 2013- Unknown Human Form Threat 01 appears in Chicago. The media comes up with various names for him, including “The Destroyer” and, “The Chicago Monster”. UHFT1 appears to be, one Mister Ewan Brown. Mr. Brown was a tax consultant known for having a bit of a temper and a large ego. He snapped and destroyed most of Chicago in a matter of hours, exhibiting the powers of flight, superstrength and the ability to project waves of lethal force from his hands. Brown is the world's first taste of Superhumans. Their next tastes are the few superhuman that are recorded standing up to Brown. The army is swift to blockade the city. There is a stalemate. Brown kills anyone who enters his city, but will not leave. Many civilians are left alive and made to worship Mr. Brown.

August 18th 2013- The Bellingham Police Station is emptied out late that night. Paul Abramson, career criminal, kills the police on duty, the other prisoners, and anyone else he comes across on his flight to freedom. There is one notable exception: Automaton. This hero is wearing homemade powered armour. The hero and the sociopath's monster fight in the streets, neither getting the upper hand until Abramson's monster vanishes, its master nowhere in sight. Meanwhile, on the other side of the district, a new superhuman makes himself know, he appears to be a teleporter with a sword.

August 19th 2013- Despite the police's best efforts, they are unable to find either Abramson or Automaton. Disappearances start in Sehome and Fairhaven. They seem more like evacuations, money and personal items are taken with no sign of struggle or forced entry. The only thing connecting them is a small stone tower, shaped like a rook, left somewhere on the property, visible from the street. Announced over the internet, a group of superhuman wannabes meet up in a fast food restaurant. Somewhat concealed among their numbers are a number of true superhumans who exchange information with each other.

August 20th 2013- Rumors appear about a teleporting creature stalking the rooftops of the city. A cluster of house fires start in Sehome. Automaton and two new heroes, dressed like high tech Greco-Roman warriors, appear at the scene and help rescue workers to extricate those trapped in the burning buildings. Automaton gives his name to reporters for the first time. The other two introduce themselves as Ares and Vulcan. While the armored heroes take up the spotlight, a masked superhuman uses their strange powers to heal those injured with a touch.

August 21th 2013- 8 police officers and 13 homeless people die when they attempt to flush Paul Abramson out of his hiding spot. Abramson escapes again in the confusion.

(Game Begins)

August 22th 2013- A group of super heroes and super villains clash at the site of a bank robbery. This fight ends with three of the heroes dead. The Superheroes were members of a team out of Seattle who came down to hunt down Paul Abramson. The remaining member of the team, a shapeshifter called Feral vows to hunt down those responsible.

August 23rd 2013- Multiple people in Bellingham report being interrogated and savagely beaten by a dark haired, beast-like man.
A group of superhumans step in to stop a jewelry store robbery. This results in the death of one of Portsmouth’s homeless, apparently one that possessed superpowers. The other two thieves surrender to the intervening superhumans and disappear with them to parts unknown.
Ares and Vulcan stop an attack on an upscale restaurant in Fairhaven by four strange, beetle-like humanoids. These creatures, upon their defeat, revered back into humans and seemed to have no memory of the events that led them to attack.
Lastly, a massive crop of strange fungus infests and destroys a medical research building in Sehome.

August 24th 2013- A anti-power militia lynches a pair of young superhumans (One with the power of flight, and the other who can generate a spray of paint-like pigment). They beat and hang the two superhumans. In retaliation, radicals from the group Powers Unite hunt down and kill those responsible.
Radicals from Powers Unite retaliate and kill the skinhead militia “True Americans”
The President declares the creation of the Anti-Human Form Threat Division or A.T.D, an organization specifically created to deal with the growing danger of Unknown Human Form Threats (i.e. Superhumans) 

August 25th 2013- The Portsmouth Heroes put Loot and Pillage on parole and use them to help bust the arms dealing Rook Gang. All except Armory and Scatter die. Armory is taken in. A mysterious masked woman in a scaled cloak retrieves Scatter. Their mansion in Sehome is the site of a mass exodus as the brainwashed victims try to go back to their homes. The Portsmouth PD cordon off the area, a retrieve the weapons contained therein.  
A new hero, Android makes his debut. He busts a drug den that the police knew about but could not get the evidence to make a move. Bristol is overthrown by someone calling himself ‘Liege’.

August 26th 2013- No major news.

August 27th 2013- Saul Hayes, of the law firm ‘Marino and Hayes’ in Bellingham releases a statement in support of the A.T.D and his firm’s resolve to deliver funds and aid to nascent alphabet organization. A banker is murdered and hung by his feet on a busy thoroughfare.

August 28th 2013- ATD sets up a branch in Bellingham under Director Anna-Maria Nesmith. The Gygax building, home to ‘Marino and Hayes’ collapses out of the blue. Abramson attacks a group of street kids, killing them all. The city of Bangalore vanishes.

Saturday, 25 January 2014

Nova: Tools and Transportation



                Relics are tools and weapons brought from the ruins below or produced by the Priests using secret methods. The relics recovered from the ruins are complex and strange and only the Priests fully understand them. Relics produced in the city are mundane items made with materials from the ruins. They are stronger, lighter, and generally better than their mundane counterparts are. These are just some of the more common or useful examples of Relics.

                The relic that every citizen and nomad are familiar with are the Skiffs. They are 10 meter long enclosed craft. Using the same method the cities use to remain afloat, Skiffs are able to float above the fog and travel between the cities and towns. They are short-range craft, only able to make journeys of a week of more before they need maintenance from a priest. The Scavengers use them to launch their expeditions down into the fog. This is to reduce the danger of arboreal predators scaling the lines and attacking a city or town. Most cities have dozens of Skiffs and the cities use much of the material recovered by Scavengers to keep their Skiffs in working order. 

                The largest common relic is a Hull. Similar to a Skiff, this is a large enclosed craft, roughly 300 meters in length. Nomads live in fleets of Hulls, travelling between cities. Each Hull carries several Skiffs, with a capacity for up to a dozen. Only the very richest cities have a Hull, and never more than one. The rest are crewed by Nomads. A Nomad Hull is similar to a city, but far more cramped. These large vehicles lack the temperamental nature of Skiffs and can go long distances without needing significant repair.

                Instead of, or supplementing their use of torches, some Scavengers carry a simple relic. Similar in design to other rod relics, the Lightrod is a foot long metallic rod which, when activated, emits a bright beam of light from one end. Symbols appear in the air above the surface of the rod and if the right combination is pressed, it changes how the rod emits light. The extra features vary from rod to rod, but all are able to generate a beam of light for between several hours, to several days. Some are able to regain their power by sitting in the sun for a while, while others require repair from a priest.

                Sometimes, a Scavenger will not want to come in contact with a dangerous creature. Maybe their reach exceeds that of even a spear. Maybe they have a potent poison. Regardless of why, sometimes a Scavenger will want a ranged weapon. Most carry bows, sometimes made by Craftspeople, sometimes crafted from scavenged materials by priests. Some Scavengers are lucky to have a relic weapon instead of a bow, these devices are called Firerods. Like a Lightrod, a Firerod is a foot long metallic rod. Unlike a Lightrod, this is a weapon. When activated, symbols appear above the surface, one end will glow red, and a small patch of light will appear on the rod’s surface. Adjusting the symbols on the surface controls the intensity of the effect. Pressing on the patch of light will cause a burning ray to erupt from the glowing end of the rod. If turned down to its minimum, the power in these rods lasts nearly forever, but sadly can only light a fire about a foot away. The burns it cause are only mildly painful. At their highest setting, they will burn a hole through a large predator. The injury is rarely enough to put one of those creatures down for good, but may slow it down enough for the Scavenger to make their escape. Once the power in a Firerod is spent, they must be returned to a priest for repair. Even more uncommon are the larger cousin of the Firerod, the Firestave. These large relics are as tall as a adult citizen and function much the same as a Firerod. However, the maximum power of a Firestave is enough to incinerate even the largest creatures of the Fog.

A Ticker is an extremely rare relic with no mundane counterpart. This item is small and typically worn as a pendant or charm. They emit a periodic ticking noise which grows louder the closer it’s bearer comes to the Fog. Once inside the Fog, the ticking grows louder still as the bearer approaches either a ruin, or a wasteland. Only an experience bearer can tell the difference between the two. They are useful but dangerous tools. An inexperienced user can stumble into a burning wasteland and suffer an agonizing death without much difficulty. Even an experienced user is unable to silence the Ticker, even when hiding from predators.

Stunrods are the primary tool of the trade for Protectors. These rod relics produce incapacitating paralysis of the limbs at first. Continued use on the same person will produce greater degrees of paralysis eventually leading to the heart and lungs ceasing to function. Scavengers dismiss them as useless because they only affect the human nervous system, leaving the dangerous wildlife of the fog completely unaffected. The most common type of Stunrod requires contact with the target. An uncommon and highly sought after version fires a thin blue beam from one end that has the same effect on contact. Before activation, they are identical to Lightrods and Firerods, this is another reason Scavengers dislike them. When scrambling for a weapon to use against a dangerous predator, finding a Stunrod can lull a rookie Scavenger into a false sense of security.

                Other Relics are common in the ruins, and Scavengers may be able to discern their function. Some play strange music. Others cause intricate light shows. Others still allow access to rooms and buildings that are otherwise inaccessible. The majority of relics are ineffable in purpose, and are either broken, as many things are in the ruins, or simply require the expert knowledge of a Priest to decipher. Regardless of their use, intended or otherwise, Scavengers bring these items to the Priests who use them as components for their strange rituals and for repairing the relics that the community finds useful.